Second Language Acquisition

Creating A Caring and Inclusive Community: Differentiation

Spread the love

Differentiated instructions

The idea of differentiation has been discussed and explored widely among schools and educators. It is an area of development for my school as recommended by our accreditation organizations. Before diving deeper into how we can provide differentiated instructions, it is worth mentioning some common misconceptions about differentiation observed by Carol Tomlinson and Marcia Imbeau as below: 

Differentiation is

  • new;
  • for a particular category of students (for example, special education, English learners, gifted education);
  • something extra that teachers have to do in addition to their “normal” plans;
  • oppositional to content standards;
  • a way to “mollycoddle” students;
  • a particular set of instructional strategies;
  • extreme teaching – something only an occasional teacher can expected to do;
  • something teachers already do.

I had these misconceptions before. When I was a young teacher first learning about differentiation, I also thought that differentiation requires teachers to implement a particular set of strategies for each student. I usually obtained many different instructional ideas from workshops about this topic, but I did not always know how to use them with my students effectively. As the authors pointed out in the book, Managing a Differentiated Classroom, “Differentiation is a way of thinking about the classroom, not a specified set of tools.” I also heard many teachers say that “We are already doing differentiation.” It’s important to point out that although teachers might use some intervention in responding to different students’ needs, the approaches used are not always proactive and/or intentional. 

“Differentiation is a way of thinking about the classroom, not a specified set of tools.” 
(Carol Tomlinson)

After reading Differentiated Instruction Made Practical: Engaging the Extremes through Classroom RoutinesI developed a greater understanding of what differentiated instruction is and is not. The authors proposed the ALL-ED (All Learners Learning Every Day) theoretical framework specifying four steps to implement differentiated instructions in this book. 

Step One: Identify OSCAR

First, teachers need to identify lesson ObjectivesStarting positionCriteriaAction pattern, and Reflections to determine any necessary adjustments to the instruction.  

Step Two: Look and Listen

Then teachers need to get to know their students and their learning profiles by gathering student responses to implement individual and group learning routines. 

Step Three: CARR Check

in this stage, teachers give formative assessment to check understanding and analyze data to determine how they can further support students. To help teachers use CARR Check, guiding questions are provided for teachers to reflect on the four elements based on the formative assessment data collected: 

  • Clarity: Is this task clear to all students? Are the words understandable by all students? Are students expected to understand the vocabulary that may be vague, have multiple meanings or are in unfamiliar contexts?
  • Access: Could all students complete the task independently and feel capable?
  • Rigor: How much effort is required of different students? What would students find complex?
  • Relevance: Would all students find this task important, interesting, valuable, and/or useful?

Step Four: SHOp Adjustments

Finally, teachers use their formative assessment data to guide their instructional decision-making and provide options according. They might need to adjust Structures for tasks, Help and provide Options to respond to perceived learner needs. (I am unsure what the ‘p’ stands for.) 

This is a very nicely put together evidence-based framework that is easy to follow. I particularly appreciated the concept that all learners learn every day. I rethink why we need to differentiate and how differentiated instruction can benefit all students. I had an a-ha moment. When teachers differentiate according to students’ interests, readiness, and learning profiles, we try to increase their motivation, academic growth and efficacy. This makes differentiation so much easy to understand. I begin to think about how this ALL-ED framework can be integrated with the IB programmes and what instructional ideas might support teachers in implementing differentiated instructions.

Here is the model I came up with: Differentiation is when everyone LEARNS

  • L: Look for patterns of need and create a safe and inclusive environment
  • E: Establish purposeful and relevant curriculum and assessment mapping
  • A: Analyze assessment data throughout to inform instruction decisions
  • R: Refer to learning objectives and provide targeted and actionable feedback
  • N: Nurture self-regulated learning behaviors and assist students in setting goals
  • S: Structure lessons that promote thinking and stretches students

There are five classroom elements that teachers can differentiate or modify: content, process, products, affect and environment. We consider students’ interests, readiness, and learning profile when differentiating any elements. Before teachers differentiate their class, we first need to consider affect (How students link thoughts and feeling in the classroom) and learning environment (the way the classroom feels and functions) as Maslow always first! Using the MYP language, I identify content as the written curriculum; the process is the taught curriculum; the product is the assessed curriculum. 

After synthesizing information from High Impact Teaching Strategies and cross-reference the 250+ Influences on Student Achievement, I identified some key strategies that teachers can use to differentiate content, process and product. I hope this model is easy to follow and helpful to teachers who want to implement differentiated instruction. 

​Creating a caring and inclusive community: differentiation

References

  • Bondie, Rhonda, and Akane Zusho. Differentiated Instruction Made Practical: Engaging the Extremes through Classroom Routines. Routledge, 2018.
  • Tomlinson, Carol Ann, and Marcia B. Imbeau. Managing a Differentiated Classroom – a Practical Guide, Scholastic Inc., 2011, pp. 10–11.
  • State of Victoria. “High Impact Teaching Strategies.” State of Victoria (Department of Education and Training), June 2017, revised and updated October 2020.
  • “250+ Influences on Student Achievement.” Visible Learning Limited Partnership and Cognition Education Group , Nov. 2017.
alison

View Comments

  • Thanks Alison I liked the structure and simplicity in which you presented. You started exactly what people struggles with. Very useful for new and experienced teachers.

  • Thanks so much for the information you have provided. Hattie and the dashboard are often overlooked but SUPER helpful when making determinations about instructional practices for all students.

Share
Published by
alison

Recent Posts

2024 Guide to Effective Curriculum Audits: Step-by-Step for Educators

Introduction In educational institutions, curriculum audits are more crucial than ever. They help you ensure…

4 weeks ago

Engage Teachers with a Dynamic Future-Focused Curriculum

Introduction Future-focused curriculum and teacher engagement are at the forefront of today's educational innovations. Their…

1 month ago

Inquiry-Based Learning: Converting 8 Challenges into Opportunities for Teachers

Introduction Inquiry-based teaching and learning has been actively promoted and implemented among different age groups.…

1 month ago

Inspiring Creativity: 3 Types of Effective Journal Prompts for Students

Introduction Unlocking creativity in students doesn't require elaborate plans. Sometimes, it's as simple as a…

1 month ago

Proactive Collaboration: Overcoming Assumptions with a Teamwork Checklist

Introduction Proactive collaboration is essential for preventing breakdowns and ensuring effective teamwork from the start.…

2 months ago

Student Engagement: Why Check-In and Check-Out Activities Support Learning with 10 Essential Ideas

Introduction Student engagement is vital for effective learning, and one powerful way to enhance it…

2 months ago